Back

Rate & Review

Johnny's Italian Steakhouse - Middleton

Share Your Feedback!

Jay Mouille 5 Star Rating: Excellent
06/08/2024
"Another great experience at Johnny’s! Our 18 year old was craving scallops, which we were blown aw..."
Read More
"Another great experience at Johnny’s! Our 18 year old was craving scallops, which we were blown away because my wife had them once and I’ve never tried them. I’m glad they had the craving because I tried them and they delicious! All of our meals were amazing and beef was perfectly cooked and s..."
Less
Anthony Villare 4 Star Rating: Good
06/05/2024
"I love the dim, lounge-like atmosphere of the place. Our server was friendly and helped us modify th..."
Read More
"I love the dim, lounge-like atmosphere of the place. Our server was friendly and helped us modify the entrees to our delight. The calamari was good, despite some pieces being a bit chewy. We enjoyed the zucchini fries even though they were a bit soggy. They simply needed to be crunchier. All at the ..."
Less
Faith F 3 Star Rating: Average
04/06/2024
"The desserts were amazing, but I was not as impressed with the food. I first got the house salad and..."
Read More
"The desserts were amazing, but I was not as impressed with the food. I first got the house salad and focaccia. The salad definitely came pre-made from the fridge as my plate was cold and the lettuce was a bit soggy. So wasn’t overall impressed with that, but the dressing was very good. The focacci..."
Less
Dave Froeming 5 Star Rating: Excellent
02/17/2024
"Now this place is a must visit! All 5 entrees were AMAZING! Great service and atmosphere. Large menu..."
Read More
"Now this place is a must visit! All 5 entrees were AMAZING! Great service and atmosphere. Large menu of awesome meals. Even the pre meal bread was warm and sooooo yummy! Thank me later!"
Less
L Fev 4 Star Rating: Good
01/28/2024
"We had a nice diner. Our server, Paige, was great! The scallops were wonderful. The broccoli base wi..."
Read More
"We had a nice diner. Our server, Paige, was great! The scallops were wonderful. The broccoli base with bacon was ?! and kind of cold. House salad was really good. My steak was good, flavorful and tender. The garlic mashed potatoes were ok. They kind of tasted like instant potatoes. The stuffed shrim..."
Less
Tracie E. 3 Star Rating: Average
02/11/2022
"I just had dinner there last night. I want to start with what went right last night. I had Marianna ..."
Read More
"I just had dinner there last night. I want to start with what went right last night. I had Marianna as a server. She was perfect. Gave me time to look over..."
Less
Allison G. 4 Star Rating: Good
09/12/2021
"My husband and I stopped by Johnny's Italian Steakhouse this weekend for a nice dinner. We sat ..."
Read More
"My husband and I stopped by Johnny's Italian Steakhouse this weekend for a nice dinner. We sat outside on the patio and ordered a couple glasses of Dona..."
Less
Cameron G. 5 Star Rating: Excellent
09/11/2021
"This was my second time here and it did not disappoint! The patio was amazing, the waitress was frie..."
Read More
"This was my second time here and it did not disappoint! The patio was amazing, the waitress was friendly and knew her stuff and the food was delicious. The..."
Less

loading